When I found out I was pregnant with my second child, my first thought was, “How wonderful!” My second thought? “What do we tell people who ask about gifts?”
Let’s face it: the etiquette around a second baby registry isn’t always clear.
Some people think it’s overstepping. Others know it’s just practical—especially if your toddler turned all your gear into abstract art with applesauce.
Should You Make a Registry for Your Second Baby?
Absolutely. Every child deserves to be celebrated, and every parent deserves support. Whether your kids are years apart or close in age, chances are there are things you still need.
Maybe your firstborn was a different gender. Maybe your old stroller is busted. Or maybe—hear us out—you just want some fresh items for your fresh new baby. That’s where a second baby registry comes in.
Why MyRegistry.com Is Perfect for Baby #2
1. Register Only for What You Need
You’re not starting from scratch—so your registry doesn’t have to be massive. With MyRegistry.com, you can add just the essentials, making it easier for friends and family to support you without guessing what’s useful.
2. Use a Cash Fund (Yes, It’s Okay!)
Let’s be honest: sometimes what you need is a little financial help. From daycare deposits to dinner deliveries, MyRegistry.com’s cash gift option makes it easy to receive support—without the awkwardness.
3. Add Gifts from Anywhere
Need a double stroller from a boutique store or a specific item from Amazon? MyRegistry’s universal feature lets you add gifts from any store in the world.
How to Keep It Polite (and Honest)
Worried how it’ll look? Add a thoughtful message to your registry:
“We’re excited to welcome baby #2! We’ve kept many essentials but registered for a few items we need or would love to refresh. Your support means so much—gifts are appreciated but never expected.”
Simple, gracious, and it sets expectations.
Second-Time Baby Registry Essentials
Here’s what real second-time parents actually register for:
Diaper Subscriptions – You’ll be changing double the diapers now.
2. Coffee. So much coffee. – Self-explanatory.
3. Double stroller – For when you need to flee the house at top speed with both children.
4. Meal Gift Cards – Because “what’s for dinner?” will haunt you daily.
Create Your Second Baby Registry Now
A second baby registry isn’t about being greedy. It’s about being smart. MyRegistry.com lets you simplify the gifting process with a registry tailored to what you really need now.
And let’s be real—your friends and family are going to want to help. You might as well guide them to what’s most useful (and avoid more musical plush toys).
Create your Baby Registry today to get the right support for baby #2 and keep your growing family well-equipped.
MyRegistry is a universal gift registry platform where you can add gifts from any store. We may earn commissions from qualifying purchases made through links in this article. Thank you for your support!
