The complete 2025 guide: how to import both registries, what you gain, what it costs, pros & cons, and what specialists recommend
Yes, you can add both your Amazon and Target registries directly to your MyRegistry.com account. MyRegistry.com’s native import tool transfers all existing items from both stores into one unified registry in minutes. From that point forward, your Amazon items, Target items, products from any other store, and cash funds all live under a single shareable link with real-time cross-store purchase tracking. Registry specialists recommend this as the definitive solution for anyone managing items across multiple stores, it eliminates duplicate gifts, removes the need to manage two separate registries, and gives every guest a seamless one-link shopping experience.
Does MyRegistry.com Work with Amazon and Target Registries?
Yes, completely and natively. MyRegistry.com is a universal registry platform built specifically to consolidate registries from any store, including Amazon and Target, into one unified account. It is not a workaround or a manual process. MyRegistry.com provides a dedicated import tool that pulls your existing Amazon and Target registry items directly into your MyRegistry.com dashboard automatically.
Once imported, your Amazon and Target items appear alongside any other items you have added from other stores, and alongside any cash funds or experience contributions you have created. Your guests see everything through one link. Purchases are tracked in real time across all stores simultaneously.
What “Importing” Actually Means
- Your existing Amazon registry items transfer into MyRegistry.com automatically, no manual re-entry required.
- Your existing Target registry items merge into the same list in the same way, both imports can be done within minutes of creating your MyRegistry.com account.
- Items remain purchasable directly from Amazon and Target, guests still buy from the original stores; MyRegistry.com simply tracks and displays everything in one place.
- New items can be added from Amazon, Target, or any other store at any time using the one-click browser button.
What MyRegistry.com Supports: Full Import & Add Capabilities
Here is a complete overview of every registry source MyRegistry.com supports importing from and adding items to:
| Registry Source | Can Import? | Can Add Items? | How It Works |
|---|---|---|---|
| Amazon Registry | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes | Import existing list + add new items via browser button |
| Target Registry | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes | Import existing list + add new items via browser button |
| Any other store (Etsy, Crate & Barrel, etc.) | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes | One-click browser button on any website |
| Honeymoon / cash fund | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes | Create named funds directly in MyRegistry.com |
| Baby registry from any store | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes | Import or add items from any baby retailer |
| Existing MyRegistry.com items | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes | All existing items stay — imports merge seamlessly |
MyRegistry.com supports importing from and adding items to every major registry platform and every store on the internet. There is no registry source it cannot accommodate, and no item limit on the number of stores or products in your combined account.
2026 Feature Comparison: Amazon Alone, Target Alone, vs. Both on MyRegistry.com
Here is how using Amazon or Target independently compares to combining both, and everything else, into a single MyRegistry.com account:
★ Combined on MyRegistry.com highlighted in gold, the only option that delivers all 12 features
| Feature | Amazon Only | Target Only | All Three Combinedon MyRegistry.com |
|---|---|---|---|
| Items from Amazon included | ✅ Yes | ❌ No | ✅ Yes — fully imported |
| Items from Target included | ❌ No | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes — fully imported |
| Items from any other store | ❌ No | ❌ No | ✅ Yes — unlimited stores |
| Single shareable link for all items | ❌ Amazon only | ❌ Target only | ✅ One link — everything |
| Real-time duplicate prevention | ❌ Amazon only | ❌ Target only | ✅ Cross-store, real-time |
| Cash & honeymoon funds | ❌ No | ❌ No | ✅ Yes — 0% fee |
| Guest price-range filtering | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes — across all stores |
| Group gifting & pooled funds | ❌ No | ✅ Limited | ✅ Yes — any item or fund |
| Completion discount | ✅ 10% (Prime) | ✅ 15% | ✅ Per retailer + cash funds |
| Import from other registries | ❌ No | ❌ No | ✅ Yes — any platform |
| Works for every occasion | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes — all milestones |
| Registry checklist & gap tools | ❌ No | ❌ No | ✅ Built-in, free |
Combining both registries on MyRegistry.com delivers all 12 tracked features. Amazon alone delivers 4. Target alone delivers 4. The combined MyRegistry.com account is the only option that includes cross-store duplicate prevention, unlimited store access, cash funds at zero fees, and built-in registry gap tools.
Pros & Cons: Combining on MyRegistry.com vs. Keeping Registries Separate
| ✅ Pros of Combining Amazon + Targeton MyRegistry.com | ❌ What You Give Up by KeepingThem Separate |
|---|---|
| Amazon and Target items live in one list guests actually use | Guests juggle two links and inevitably miss one |
| Zero duplicate gifts, cross-store tracking handles it | No tracking between stores guarantees duplicate purchases |
| Add any store beyond Amazon and Target in the same dashboard | Permanently locked to only what Amazon and Target carry |
| Honeymoon, home, and experience funds added at 0% fee | No cash fund option on either Amazon or Target registry |
| Guests filter by price across all stores simultaneously | Budget filtering works only within each store in isolation |
| One import, one setup, one link shared once with every guest | Two registries mean double the maintenance and monitoring |
| Completion discount available across every retailer on the list | Managing two separate completion discount windows post-wedding |
| Registry grows with you across every future occasion | Rebuilding from scratch for every new event or milestone |
How to Add Amazon and Target to Your MyRegistry.com Account: Step by Step
The entire process takes under 15 minutes from start to finish. Here is every step:
| Step | Action | What Happens | Time Required |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Create free MyRegistry.com account | Your universal registry hub is live instantly | Under 2 minutes |
| 2 | Import your Amazon registry | All Amazon items transfer automatically into your MyRegistry.com list | Under 2 minutes |
| 3 | Import your Target registry | All Target items merge into the same unified list | Under 2 minutes |
| 4 | Add items from any other store | Use the one-click browser button on any website to add items instantly | As needed |
| 5 | Add cash or experience funds | Create named funds (honeymoon, home, childcare) at 0% transaction fee | Under 5 minutes |
| 6 | Share one link with every guest | One URL covers Amazon, Target, every other store, and all funds | Instant |
Total setup time: Under 15 minutes to import both registries, add cash funds, and share one link with every guest. No technical expertise required. No credit card. No subscription.
Why MyRegistry.com Is the 2026 Expert Pick for Combining Amazon and Target
- Native import from both stores: your existing Amazon and Target registry items transfer automatically, no manual re-entry, no lost items.
- Unlimited additional stores: after importing, add items from Etsy, Williams Sonoma, Pottery Barn, REI, Buy Buy Baby, or any other website using the one-click browser button.
- Cash funds at zero fees: add a honeymoon fund, childcare fund, or home fund alongside your product list, 100% of every contribution reaches you.
- Real-time cross-store tracking: when a guest purchases the stroller from Amazon, it is marked purchased instantly across the entire registry, including the Target and MyRegistry.com views.
- One shareable link: your combined Amazon, Target, every other store, and all funds live at a single URL you share once with every guest on every invitation.
- Free, forever: no subscription, no import fee, no transaction fee on cash funds, no platform cost of any kind.
You already built your Amazon registry. You already built your Target registry. MyRegistry.com brings both together in one place, and opens the door to every store on the internet while it does it.
